Managed Print Services vs Buying Your Own Printers

Managed Print Services vs Buying Your Own Printers

Printers are one of the few pieces of office equipment most small businesses still buy the same way they did twenty years ago — outright purchase, deal with toner and repairs as they come up — even though a managed print services contract often works out cheaper and far less disruptive once you actually run the numbers.

What Managed Print Services Actually Includes

A managed print services (MPS) contract typically bundles the printer hardware itself, consumables (toner, drums), maintenance and repair, and usage monitoring into one predictable per-page or monthly cost — instead of separate line items for the printer purchase, toner reorders, and the occasional emergency repair call.

Cost Comparison: The Real Math

Cost factor Buying Your Own Managed Print Services
Upfront cost Full hardware purchase price Usually $0 or minimal upfront
Toner/consumables Pay full retail, often reordered reactively Bundled into per-page cost, auto-replenished
Repairs Out of pocket, unpredictable timing Included in contract
Predictability Low — costs spike with breakdowns High — fixed or near-fixed monthly cost

Where Buying Outright Still Makes Sense

For very low print volume, or a single backup printer that barely gets used, the ongoing per-page costs of an MPS contract may not pencil out compared to just buying a modest printer outright and replacing toner as needed. MPS value scales with print volume — the busier your print environment, the more the bundled model tends to win. A reliable business laser printer is worth the investment for low-volume use. See our DIY IT vs. managed services guide for the same buy-vs-outsource logic applied more broadly across your IT stack.

Contract Terms Worth Scrutinizing

Pay close attention to the per-page overage rate beyond your contracted volume tier, minimum monthly commitments, and the actual hardware refresh schedule included in the contract — some MPS deals look attractively cheap on the headline rate but carry steep overage charges that erase the savings for a business with variable print volume.

Hidden Costs of Buying Your Own That Often Get Missed

IT staff time spent troubleshooting printer issues, ordering and tracking toner inventory, and coordinating repair technicians all have a real cost that rarely shows up on a budget line item but adds up over a printer’s service life. Keeping compatible toner cartridges in stock avoids a last-minute scramble when one runs dry mid-project. See our small business printer setup guide for what that ongoing maintenance burden actually looks like day to day.

Printers Are a Network Security Surface Too

Printers run their own embedded firmware, often ship with default admin credentials nobody changes, and sit on the same network as everything else — making them a documented pivot point for attackers who get a foothold through an unpatched or default-credentialed printer. This is a factor worth weighing either way: some (not all) managed print contracts include firmware patching and credential hardening as part of the service, while a printer you buy and manage yourself needs that same discipline applied manually. Ask any MPS vendor specifically whether security patching is included, rather than assuming it is.

Fitting This Into Your Broader IT Budget

Printing is a small line item individually, but across a full office fleet it adds up — treat the buy-vs-managed decision as part of your overall IT budgeting process rather than a one-off purchasing question handled in isolation. See our small business IT budget planning guide for where print costs fit into the bigger picture.

Bottom Line

Managed print services usually wins on predictability and total cost for any office with meaningful print volume, while buying outright can still make sense for very light, low-maintenance use — run the actual per-page math for your specific volume rather than assuming either model is automatically cheaper.


Official sources: U.S. Small Business Administration, ENERGY STAR — Office Equipment.

Similar Posts